Newsday/News 12 investigation: Innocent man wrongfully convicted?Posted: Updated:
Imagine going to prison for a murder you didn't commit?
In a Newsday/News 12 investigation, reporter Thomas Maier examines the case of Keith Bush and whether an innocent man was wrongfully convicted and if the real killer got away.
Keith Bush was 17 years old in January 1975, when Suffolk police charged him with killing Sherese Watson.
The 14-year-old girl was strangled and stabbed. Her body was found in an empty lot in North Bellport, not far, police say, from where the two had attended a late-night party.
Bush was found guilty of murder and attempted sexual abuse. He spent 33 years behind bars, all while trying to clear his name.
Turns out something was wrong. At age 61, Bush recently learned Suffolk authorities had another possible suspect.
Newly revealed documents show John W. Jones Jr., then a 21-year-old woodworker, admitted in 1975 that he was at the scene the night of the murder.
Jones said he tripped over the dead girl's body and left behind his plastic comb, which was found beside the victim.
Suffolk authorities never disclosed anything about Jones at Bush's trial. It would remain a secret for the next four decades, while Bush spent most of his adult life behind bars.
A News12/Newsday investigation found other signs that could point to Bush's innocence.
Forensic reports show male DNA found on the dead girl's body that wasn't from Bush.
There are also allegations that Bush's signed confession was the result of a police beating, something the department denied and a key witness who changed her story.
Maxine Bell says she was a scared homeless kid, afraid of getting in trouble, when she became the prosecution's key witness.
However, a judge ruled that Bell's accusations provided enough probable cause for Suffolk police to question Bush for hours in 1975. In the end, detectives got a written statement from him admitting guilt. Bush says detectives wrote it for him and beat him for hours until he signed it.
At his trial, Suffolk police denied any wrongdoing with the confession and at age 18, Bush was sent to state prison, insisting on his innocence and that the real killer had gotten away.
News 12 reached out to the top detective who handled the Bush case, but he declined to speak with reporters.
The prosecutor in the trial is now dead, and former Suffolk DA Thomas Spota said he didn't remember the case.
- A West Hempstead man is facing charges after a public lewdness incident in Malverne Park Oaks.A West Hempstead man is facing charges after a public lewdness incident in Malverne Park Oaks.
It's a battle for bragging rights! News 12 is looking for the schools with the most school spirit! Is it yours?
- Local and state officials are pushing to get cleaner drinking water on Long Island, and some are looking west for a solution.
- Aside from banks, Netflix was one of the big earnings releases of the week.Aside from banks, Netflix was one of the big earnings releases of the week.
- A fall favorite made its return to Oyster Bay this weekend -- it's the annual Oyster Festival.A fall favorite made its return to Oyster Bay this weekend -- it's the annual Oyster Festival.
- Men and women in blue took to the field at Baldwin Harbor Park for a "Strike Out Suicide" charity softball game.
- Two people were injured in a single-car crash in Melville early Saturday morning, and police say the driver had a suspended license.
- Just in time for its 100th Anniversary, National Sweetest Day encourages everyone to be generous even in the smallest ways.
- This week's workout comes from Chris LoVarco at American Black Belt Academy.This week's workout comes from Chris LoVarco at American Black Belt Academy.
- DJ LeMahieu and Aaron Hicks stunned Justin Verlander with first-inning home runs, James Paxton made the early lead stand up and the New York Yankees beat Houston 4-1 Friday night, cutting the Astros' lead in the AL Championship Series to 3-2.
- This week's dogs are up for adoption at Almost Home Animal Rescue & Adoption. The shelter is located at 646 Medford Ave. in Patchogue. Their phone number is (631) 627-3665.
- Heavy right and high winds swept through the tri-state area due to a large coast storm on the night of Oct. 16. Here are your photos from the storm.
- Photos on the field of the New York Yankees in the 2019 American League Division Series vs. the Minnesota Twins.
- Are you and your family doing fun things this fall? Whether you're out apple or pumpkin picking, at a farm or corn maze or just hanging around in your home or yard, News 12 Long Island wants to see your Fall Fun pics!
- Did you do something fun with your kids this weekend? Share your adventure with us!Did you do something fun with your kids this weekend? Share your adventure with us!
Looking to check out brewery this summer? There are many breweries across the island for beer-lovers to visit.
- Gunfire broke out inside an illegal gambling club in Brooklyn early Saturday, police said, leaving four people dead, three wounded, and investigators trying to piece together what prompted the bloodshed.
- News 12's Stone Grissom is dishin' some fun T-shirts during his award-winning Dishin' Long Island segments! What fun shirt will he wear next?
- Looking for a place to listen to some music or see a local play? Here is a list of concert venues in the Tri-state area.
- The 2019 performer lineup for Madison Square Garden.The 2019 performer lineup for Madison Square Garden.